Shariah Screening & Islamic Indices
Login to continue watching
This video is available to members only.
Shariah Screening & Islamic Indices
Duration
07m 58s
https://app.islamicmarkets.com/video/shariah-screening-islamic-indices
Shariah Screening and Islamic Indices.
The last century has seen an acceleration and
unimaginable growth in the way investments are made.
All due to the intertwining of finance technology
and better infrastructure.
Muslims have invested and traded
since the initial days of revelation.
While the Quran encourages trade and investment
and provides guidance for how muslims should
approach these activities,
formalized financial processes did not
begin to develop until the mid 20th century.
The first Shariah compliant mutual fund was
launched in Malaysia in 1979
and it was one of the world's first attempts to get
Shariah screening guidelines for such investments.
Preliminary guidelines were developed by scholars.
However this was just the beginning of the journey.
Over the last 40 years,
the Shariah screening guidelines have
continue fully developed and enhanced
as scholars continuously seek to apply
the teachings of the Quran and the Sunnah
in every facet of life in the most accurate manner.
In 1986, the famous Amanah Income Fund
was launched in the US.
This became the second Shariah compliant fund
that was launched in the world.
Despite this monumental milestone,
the Shariah guidelines for screening
are still not formerly developed.
Then in 1990, several Islamic financial institutions
from across the globe gathered to develop and
issue industry standards which gave birth to the
Accounting and Auditing Organization
for Islamic Financial Institutions,
AAOIFI.
In 2004, AAOIFI issued Shariah standard
number 21 on Financial Paper
which offered comprehensive Shariah investment
guidelines and screening criteria.
On the other hand,
Malaysia was experiencing tremendous growth
in Islamic finance and as a result
the Securities Commission Malaysia
developed early screening criteria.
In 2013, they revised their Islamic guidelines
to be more rigorous illustrating
the iterative process required
for maintaining such standards.
To identify which stocks are Islamic
the industry created new capital markets indices
to capture Shariah compliant stocks
according to different screening methodology is.
The first Islamic index introduced,
by Dow Jones in 1997 introduced
Islamic investing to a much wider audience.
Today the industry counts a handful of
Islamic Indices under Standard and Poor's
Dow Jones islamic,
FTSE
and MSCI
All of the islamic indices are composed of
two different screening stages
qualitative screening
and quantitative screening.
The first stage of qualitative screening excludes
businesses and sectors which are involved
in Shariah non compliance activities
such as conventional financial services
gambling
pork and unlawful food production.
alcohol production
tobacco dissemination etc.
These industries go against the teachings
of Islam and investing in any such area goes
against the values and visits by Islam for society.
The industry uses different references
when it comes to Shariah screening.
These are the top ones
AAOIFI
Dow Jones Islamic
FTSE Shariah
MSCI Islamic
Securities Commission Malaysia
S&P 500 Shariah
At the first stage of qualitative screening
each of these focuses on either the industry sector
or business activity of the company
to identify it's involvement in the
prohibited activities.
For some, they screen out companies have
any prohibited activity is their core business.
While others put a threshold to determine
the partial involvement of companies
in any prohibited activity
before considering them Shariah non-compliant.
Then comes the second stage of quantitative
screening which varies among the different indices.
This screening considers the financials
of companies such as 1
cash and interest-bearing receivables
2
interest bearing debt
and 3, impermissible income.
Going back to the main references
used by the industry globally
each screening standard or Islamic Index
uses specific ratios
to determine the maximum threshold tolerated
of impure money
in the company's financials.
This is a snapshot of the different ratios used
by each index or Shariah screening standard.
Most of the indices are in consensus when
it comes to cash and interest receivables
that the maximum allowance is somewhere
between 30 and 33 per cent.
This is similar to the interest bearing
receivables in the conventional debt filter
which also ranges from 30 to 33 per cent
One goal of a Shariah compliant portfolio
is to have as little conventional debt as possible.
Islamic investment funds originally
looked for issue which was with zero debt
but that limited the universe of
investment options to severely
criteria how to develop over time
and a 33 percent debt to total assets or
total market capitalization ratio
opened up the greatest opportunity for investments
while still limiting potential downsides.
One of the main differences between
these standards and indices in the ratios used
is the denominator they use for their calculations.
Total assets vs market capitalization
Opinions on how to best evaluate company
have differed over time.
The difference comes down to whether a companies
should be evaluated based on the value of its goods
or based on the value the market is willing to pay.
When it comes to the impermissible income filter,
it varies among the indices.
The lowest tolerated figure is 5 per cent
while the highest is 25 per cent
under certain circumstances.
This commonly accepted rules stipulates that
any revenues a company receives from haram
prohibited sources
such as selling alcoholic products
must be limited to 5 per cent or
less of their total revenue.
The threshold was established in the belief
that any percentage of a business activity
above 5 per cent
changes the character of the company.
These rules have gone through many decades of
evaluation and reevaluation
and illustrates how standards are recursive
They can evolve over time while
maintaining allegiance to god's intentions
As the Islamic finance industry develops,
these standards will continue
to be reviewed and develop.
At present most Shariah screenings practice
a process of negative screening
which is the exclusion of specific industries
In fact the negative screening process
is also used among
Social and Responsible Investing Strategies (SRI).
It wasn't until 2010 that SRI began
to gain momentum among mainstream investors.
The new familiarity with SRI strategies
grew in tandem with the increase in
Environmental Social and Governance data
ESG available to investors.
When ESG data is considered alongside
financial analysis in the investment process
is known as ESG Integration.
Simultaneously SRI has evolved
to include more nuanced forms of investing
and now frequently stands for
Sustainable Responsible and Impact Investing.
If forbidding what is wrong in one's
investments is only half of one's duties,
it follows that Muslim investors should also seek to
enjoining good as the verse of the Quran states.
Just as negative screening
allows investors to exclude
impermissible activities from their portfolios,
positive screening allows asset managers to use
ESG data to identify companies with strong values
and positive social and environmental impacts.
Welcome to IslamicMarkets
A platform that connects world renowned leaders and
experts with participants in the Islamic economy.
Welcome to IslamicMarkets
A platform that connects world renowned leaders and
experts with participants in the Islamic economy.